| 2007 |
| Sarah Grace |
Baylor University |
| Jessica Maas |
The Citadel |
| Mollie Biega |
Texas A&M Kingsville |
| Laura Eidson |
Texas A&M Kingsville |
| Quinette Tramble |
Texas A&M Kingsville |
| Kenzie Bukolt |
Southern Methodist University |
| 2004 |
| Jennifer Kirkham |
Baylor (club) |
| 2002 |
| Lauren Jackson |
Trinity |
| Klarysa Henry |
Wake Forest |
| 2001 |
| Amanda Swanstrom |
Rhodes College |
| Deborah Kirkham |
Stephen F. Austin State University |
| Melissa Munsch |
Texas A&M |
| 1998 |
| Christy Rhodes |
Stephen F. Austin State University |
| Marissa Dorcheu |
Stephen F. Austin State University |
| Susanne Wright |
Sam Houston State University |
| 1996 |
| Michelle Frazier |
University of Florida |
| Jennifer Wittenburg |
UCLA, University of Houston |
| Lauren Dorcheus |
Ole Miss |
| Christy Lucas |
Texas A&M |
| Celia Howes |
Texas A&M |
| Kristen Engelking |
Colorado |
| 1995 |
| Sarah Lodge |
Colorado |
| Dana White |
University of Texas |
| 1994 |
| Amanda Sweat |
West Texas A&M |
| Sammy Waldron |
Rice University |
| Nicole Cleaney |
Ole Miss |
| Sally Emerson |
Houston Baptist University, University of Houston |
| 1990 |
| Shelley Williams |
University of Texas |
| Amy Hammond |
Western Oklahoma |
| Amy Maddox Hncir |
Texas A&M Commerce |
| Amy Waddell |
Trinity |
| Wendy Walling Loria |
Stephen F. Austin State University |
| Lisa Yensen |
Washington State |
